Group says it has legal standing to sue over Boys Ranch... | KXNet.com North Dakota News

log in|register
KXMB CBS12

Group says it has legal standing to sue over Boys Ranch...

Group says it has legal standing to sue over Boys Ranch

Bismarck, N.D. (AP) The nation's largest group of atheists and agnostics says there is legal precedent for its court challenge of foster care referrals by the state of North Dakota.

A state government lawyer who recently asked a federal judge to throw out the case disagrees.

The Wisconsin-based Freedom From Religion Foundation alleges that referrals to the Dakota Boys and Girls Ranch, which serves troubled children, are unconstitutional because the children are indoctrinated with religion. The group sued last summer.

Attorneys for the defendants want the case dismissed. They say the foundation doesn't have any legal grounds to sue, for several reasons.

Richard Bolton is an attorney for the plaintiffs, which include the foundation and some North Dakota taxpayers. He says that if they don't have standing to sue, that means state government officials would be free to violate the Constitution without fear of being challenged.

(Copyright 2008 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.) APNP 01-25-08 1055CST | save this article / add to your favorites list


Related Content
Related KXNet.com Topics




Comments Posted by KXNet.com Users

Posted by ron williams on Jan 26 2008 4:26PM - I think that our attempts to "fix" our youth are independent of religious beliefs. In no way should these beliefs drizzle their way into the counseling setting, residential or otherwise. Spirituality, given any definiition, should be a very personal thing, and one's "redemption" to society has little to do with it.
These youth clearinghouses, intent on counseling out youth and helping them to adopt ways and habits that are healthy, and then returning them to society, need to stick to secular strategies. This is a no brainer. Venture away from what it secular, and you've become an additional instrument of child abuse.

Posted by a. on Jan 27 2008 11:13PM - They have legal standing alright. The precedent which most strongly supports their case is Teen Ranch v. Udow.

All post and comments are subject to review and filtering by the KXNet.com Webmaster -

Any posts containing offensive language, threats, or any other form of abuse will be DELETED

In addition, all posts are logged and tracked in our database system including the IP Address and source computer details of the individual who submitted the post. All users commenting on KXNet.com articles and talk-forums are bound by the rules outlined in our Comment, Blog and Talk Forum Rules and are required to login as a registered member.

Click here for the KXNet.com Commenting Rules


Jump To: talk forums | blogs
Opinion, Blogs and Discussions
Most Commented Stories
  • Drunken driving deaths fall in 32 states, not ND ( 8 Comments )
  • Mountrail County officials seek 55 mph speed limit on some roads... ( 6 Comments )
  • No GEM's Allowed ( 3 Comments )
  • No easy answers after diabetic's crash ( 2 Comments )
  • Trend of teens sending nude photos on cell phones surfacing in... ( 2 Comments )
  • Ten dead in Utah plane crash ( 2 Comments )
  • Palin offers first television interview to ABC ( 1 Comments )
  • Cougar sightings reported northeast of Bismarck ( 1 Comments )
  • Talk Forum Discussions
    Blogs
    Related Categories

    jump to a KXNet category:







    Contact KXNet.com

    Part of the KXNet.com North Dakota News Network
    Dickinson News - KXMA | Bismarck News - KXMB | Minot News - KXMC | Williston News - KXMA


    North Dakota Sports | Dickinson Sports | Bismarck Sports | Minot Sports | Williston Sports


    NEW! - Try the DakotaPolitics.com BETA site!
    North Dakota Politics and Government






    KXNet is part of the Midkota Media Network
    Free Classified Ads
    Bismarck Classifieds | Minot Classifieds | Williston Classifieds | Dickinson Classifieds | Jamestown Classifieds | Devils Lake Classifieds | Fargo Classifieds


    Total Outdoor Network
    North Dakota Outdoors | South Dakota Outdoors | Minnesota Outdoors | Nebraska Outdoors | Alaska Outdoors


    Fun and Entertainment
    BismanROCKS.com - Bismarck Mandan Music | BismanWeddings.com







    Designed and Programmed By Midkota Solutions